News about a sequel was announced in June 2024. At the time, Warner Bros. shared a series of clips from the film on social media to confirm that "Practical Magic 2" was in the works.

Variety reports that the upcoming film is adapted from a later book in Hoffman’s Practical Magic series. Warner Bros. announced the movie’s release date with an ominous trailer featuring Kidman and Bullock chanting,

On Tuesday, May 6, Warner Bros. Pictures announced the expected release date for the “Practical Magic” sequel with a video that features a witch-like incantation. “Tooth of wolf and morning dew,” Kidman says to begin the video.